The dividing line is 500 passengers
IAATO, the association of Antarctic tour operators, states that vessels carrying more than 500 passengers are not allowed to land any passengers while in Antarctic waters. Below that number, ships may land, with no more than 100 visitors ashore at one site at a time.
So the first question is simple. Do you want to walk on Antarctica, or see it from the ship? Every other choice follows from that.
Expedition ships
These ships exist to get you off the ship. Days are built around Zodiac landings and Zodiac cruising, led by an expedition team, with talks on board in between. HX Expeditions, Aurora Expeditions, National Geographic-Lindblad Expeditions, Swan Hellenic, Atlas Ocean Voyages and Viking all work this way.
They differ in size and emphasis. The four National Geographic ships carry 102 to 148 guests. Aurora Expeditions carries up to 130 on expedition voyages and offers add-on activities such as kayaking, diving and ski touring. HX Expeditions sails larger ships of up to 500 guests with a Science Center on board. Viking carries 378 guests on each of its two ships.
This kind of trip suits travelers who put time outdoors first and are comfortable in a Zodiac. Seabourn, for one, says guests who cannot safely board a Zodiac unassisted will not be permitted to leave the ship where Zodiacs are the only way ashore. Ask about mobility before you choose.
Luxury expedition ships
The same landings, with the comforts of a small luxury ship. What each line states:
Silversea
A personal butler for guests. Silver Endeavour carries 220 guests with 207 crew, which Silversea describes as a 1:1 crew-to-guest ratio.
Seabourn
Seabourn Venture and Seabourn Pursuit each have 132 oceanfront veranda suites and carry 24 Zodiacs and kayaks. Seabourn describes two custom-built six-guest submarines, offered as optional excursions at an additional charge.
Scenic
Butler service in every suite, and 200 guests in Antarctica. Each ship carries two helicopters and a submersible. Scenic says these are at additional charge and subject to regulatory approval, availability, medical approval, weather and ice.
Ponant
Le Commandant Charcot carries a maximum of 245 guests in 123 staterooms and suites, with 215 crew.
Large-ship scenic cruising
Princess and Holland America include Antarctica as part of longer South America voyages on large ships. You do not go ashore in Antarctica.
Princess sails the 3,560-guest Majestic Princess on a 17-day voyage round trip from Buenos Aires with four days in the Antarctic region. It names the Gerlache Strait, Elephant Island and the South Shetland Islands, with naturalists on board to point out wildlife and scenery. Princess says its ship sails past key locations rather than disembarking, and notes that it is an IAATO member.
Holland America describes four days cruising Antarctica with commentary from its naturalists, on voyages such as its 22-day South America and Antarctica itinerary aboard Nieuw Amsterdam. Its 2025-2026 planner states that there will be no landings in Antarctica and that the exact route depends on permissions, ice, weather and time available.
Who each kind suits
| Kind of trip | Suits | Does not suit |
|---|---|---|
| Expedition ship | Travelers who want the most time ashore and in Zodiacs, and who value the expedition team over the suite. | Anyone who cannot manage a Zodiac, or who wants resort-style space and choice on board. |
| Luxury expedition ship | Travelers who want landings and also a suite, a butler and fine dining at the end of the day. | Those who want the smallest groups ashore. Most of these ships carry 200 to 274 guests and land in rotation. |
| Large-ship scenic cruise | Travelers who want to see Antarctica as part of a longer South America voyage, with full big-ship amenities and no Zodiacs. | Anyone who wants to set foot on the continent or stand among penguins. There are no landings. |
Questions
Do Princess and Holland America land passengers in Antarctica?
No. Princess says its ship sails past key locations rather than disembarking, and Holland America's 2025-2026 planner states there will be no landings in Antarctica. IAATO bars landings from vessels carrying more than 500 passengers.
What makes an expedition ship a luxury expedition ship?
The landings are the same. The difference is on board: Silversea provides a personal butler, Seabourn's two ships are all oceanfront veranda suites, and Scenic offers butler service in every suite plus helicopters and a submersible at additional charge.
How many days do the scenic cruises spend in Antarctica?
Princess lists four days in the Antarctic region on its 17-day voyage. Holland America describes four days cruising Antarctica. Routes depend on ice and weather.
Which kind of trip is right if I have limited mobility?
Landings depend on Zodiacs. Seabourn states that guests who cannot safely board a Zodiac unassisted will not be permitted to leave the ship where Zodiacs are the only way ashore. A scenic cruise involves no Zodiacs.